Bold Subscriptions has been a go-to choice for Shopify merchants wanting to add recurring revenue to their stores.
But with pricing changes and evolving feature requirements, many store owners are exploring what else is out there.
The subscription app market has exploded with options. Some focus on rock-bottom pricing.
Others prioritize advanced retention features or enterprise-grade analytics.
The right choice depends on your store size, subscription volume, and what you're actually trying to achieve.
This guide breaks down 7 top Bold Subscriptions alternatives, each vetted for Shopify compatibility.
We'll compare real pricing, key features, and who each solution fits best.
Editor’s note: Want to hear some sample AI support calls made for your Shopify store?
- Just paste your store URL
- Get sample calls in under 20 seconds (no email required)
- Listen to demo calls for my store
What to look for in a Bold Subscriptions alternative
Not all subscription apps are created equal. Here's what actually matters when you're evaluating alternatives:
- Pricing structure Most apps charge a monthly fee plus transaction fees. Some offer 0% transaction fees but higher monthly costs. You'll want to do the math based on your subscription revenue.
- Customer portal quality Your subscribers need to manage their orders easily. Look for passwordless login, mobile responsiveness, and customization options that fit your brand.
- Migration ease Moving from Bold means transferring customer data, payment methods, and active subscriptions. White-glove migration support can save you weeks of headaches.
- Shopify integration depth "Built for Shopify" status matters. Deep integration means smoother checkout flows, better analytics, and fewer technical issues down the road.
- Dunning and churn management Failed payment recovery and cancellation flows directly impact your bottom line. These features often separate the good apps from the great ones.
Quick comparison of Bold Subscriptions alternatives
Seven Bold Subscriptions alternatives for Shopify stores
1. Recurpay
Recurpay has gained serious traction as a Bold alternative, with over 175 brands migrating from Bold in the last 90 days alone. The pitch is simple: similar features at a much lower price point.
The free plan is genuinely usable for small stores, though the 3.5% transaction fee eats into margins as you scale. The Grow plan at $19/month drops that to 2%, which is competitive for most merchants doing $5k-20k in monthly subscription revenue. It's a solid option if you're watching costs.
Key features:
- Passwordless customer portal login
- Tiered discounting and free gift offers
- Native cart upsell functionality
- Smart dunning management for failed payments
- 24/7 live chat support
Pricing:
Best for: Merchants looking to reduce subscription app costs without sacrificing core functionality. The free white-glove migration from Bold is a nice bonus.
2. Appstle
Appstle boasts the highest rating in the Shopify subscription category with a perfect 5.0 stars from over 5,800 reviews. That's a level of customer satisfaction you can't ignore.
What stands out is the 0% transaction fee structure across all plans. You pay for the monthly subscription and that's it. For high-volume stores, this can mean substantial savings compared to competitors charging 1-3% per transaction.
The feature set is comprehensive. Build-a-box functionality lets customers create custom bundles. Inventory forecasting helps prevent stockouts on subscription products.
Key features:
- Build-a-box and bundling capabilities
- Inventory forecasting and alerts
- Custom shipping profiles
- Real-time analytics dashboard
- Passwordless customer portal
- Bulk action automations
Pricing:
Best for: Merchants who want a feature-rich solution with predictable costs. The free plan is limited but paid plans scale reasonably.
3. Loop Subscriptions
Loop positions itself as the retention-focused alternative. While most subscription apps help you sell, Loop emphasizes keeping subscribers around longer. It's a subtle but important difference.
The standout feature is the personalized cancellation flow. Instead of a simple "cancel" button, Loop presents retention offers, pause options, and feedback collection. According to their data, this reduces churn by 15-25% for most merchants who use it.
The customer portal is highly customizable with themes and multilingual support. The Smart Dunning system retries failed payments at optimal times based on customer behavior patterns, which helps recover revenue you'd otherwise lose.
Key features:
- Smart dunning with behavioral retry logic
- Personalized cancellation flows with retention offers
- Fixed and custom bundles
- Prepaid subscription options (Pro plan)
- Subscriber rewards and loyalty features
- API and webhooks access
Pricing:
Best for: Brands where customer lifetime value is the primary metric. The higher starting price pays off if you're serious about retention.
4. Skio
Skio is the premium option on this list, with pricing that reflects its positioning. But for the right merchant, the investment can absolutely be worth it.
The unique differentiator is group subscriptions. Think family plans, team subscriptions, or any scenario where multiple people share one subscription. This opens up new pricing models that most competitors can't support.
The analytics suite is genuinely enterprise-grade. Advanced segmentation lets you analyze subscriber behavior by cohort, acquisition channel, or custom attributes.
Key features:
- Group subscription discounts and family plans
- Full analytics suite with advanced segmentation
- SkioSMS for two-way customer communication
- Multi-step cancellation flow builder
- Smart upsell carousel (AI-driven)
- Granular user permissions for team access
Pricing:
Best for: Growing DTC brands with $50k+ in monthly subscription revenue who need advanced features and can justify the premium pricing.
5. Recharge
Recharge is the established giant in this space, powering over $30 billion in subscription revenue. When you choose Recharge, you're buying into proven infrastructure that'll scale with you.
The integration ecosystem is unmatched. Recharge connects with virtually every major e-commerce tool: Klaviyo for email, Gorgias for support, LoyaltyLion for rewards. If you've got a complex tech stack, Recharge probably plays nice with it.
The downside is the transaction fee structure. The Starter plan at $99/month still charges 1.49% + 19¢ per transaction. For a store doing $100k in monthly subscription revenue, that's nearly $1,500 in fees on top of the monthly cost. You'll need to factor this into your budget.
Key features:
- Subscription-first product page widget
- Smart cancellation prevention tools
- Failed payment recovery (up to 88% recovery rate)
- Win-back campaigns for lapsed subscribers
- Concierge SMS (Plus plan)
- Loyalty and referral program integration
Pricing:
Best for: Established merchants who prioritize reliability and integrations over cost savings. The Plus plan includes hands-on implementation support.
6. Seal Subscriptions
Seal takes a different approach: fair pricing with 0% transaction fees across all plans. You pay for the features you need based on subscriber count, not your revenue.
The free plan supports up to 50 subscriptions, making it genuinely useful for testing the subscription model without commitment. Paid plans scale from $5.95/month for 100 subscriptions up to $399/month for 150,000 subscriptions. It's hard to beat for getting started.
The feature set covers all the basics: auto-charging, recurring invoices, dunning management, and customer portal customization. It won't compete with Loop on retention features or Skio on analytics, but it handles the fundamentals well enough for most small stores.
Key features:
- Regular and prepaid subscription plans
- Auto-charging and recurring invoice options
- Custom email HTML for branded communications
- Automated product swaps
- Multilanguage support
- Robust API and webhooks
Pricing:
Best for: Small stores and merchants just starting with subscriptions. The 0% transaction fees make costs predictable as you grow.
7. Utterbond
Utterbond offers a middle-ground option with competitive pricing and 0% transaction fees on paid plans. The free plan includes unlimited subscriptions and orders (with a 2% transaction fee), which is more generous than what most competitors offer.
The feature set is solid for the price point. The Growth plan at $29/month includes prepaid subscriptions, bundle building, and gift subscriptions. The Enterprise plan adds API support and custom development options if you need them.
Migration support is a focus area. Utterbond offers migration from other apps as a standard feature, not a premium add-on. The onboarding process is designed to get you live quickly, which helps if you're in a hurry to switch.
Key features:
- Unlimited subscriptions on all plans
- Dunning and cancellation management
- Bundle (build-a-box) functionality
- Gift subscriptions
- Customer segmentation
- API support (Enterprise)
Pricing:
Best for: Merchants wanting predictable pricing without transaction fees. The annual discounts (20% off) make it even more attractive for committed users.
How to choose the right Bold Subscriptions alternative
With seven solid options, how do you decide? Here's a simple framework based on your situation.
Just starting with subscriptions:Seal or Appstle. Both offer genuinely usable free plans to test the waters.
Budget is the primary concern:Recurpay. The Grow plan at $19/month with 2% transaction fees is hard to beat for value.
Retention and LTV are your focus:Loop. The cancellation flows and dunning management justify the higher starting price.
High volume ($50k+/month subscription revenue):Skio or Recharge. The advanced analytics and enterprise features become worth the premium.
Want zero transaction fees:Appstle, Seal, or Utterbond. Each offers 0% transaction fee plans at different price points.
Making the switch from Bold Subscriptions
Migrating subscription platforms is nerve-wracking. Active subscribers, payment methods, and historical data all need to transfer cleanly. There's a lot that could go wrong.
Most alternatives on this list offer migration support, but the process varies:
- Export your data from Bold subscription details, customer info, payment tokens
- Choose your timing avoid peak sales periods, plan for 1-2 weeks of transition
- Communicate with subscribers give customers a heads up about portal changes
- Test thoroughly run parallel systems briefly to catch any issues
- Leverage migration support Recurpay, Appstle, and Loop all offer white-glove migration services
The good news: most migrations complete without customers noticing. Payment methods transfer seamlessly, and subscription schedules remain intact. You shouldn't lose any sleep over it if you plan properly.
Start optimizing your subscription business today
The subscription app you choose impacts everything from your margins to your customer experience. Each alternative on this list solves the core problem of managing recurring orders, but they differ significantly in pricing, features, and focus. You'll want to pick carefully.
Take the time to match the tool to your actual needs. A small store doesn't need Skio's enterprise analytics. A high-volume brand will outgrow Seal's simpler feature set pretty quickly.
Once you've got your subscription platform sorted, consider how you handle subscriber support. Ringly.io offers AI-powered phone support that integrates with your Shopify store, handling order lookups, subscription changes, and common questions automatically. It's a natural complement to any subscription app, freeing up your team to focus on growth while keeping subscribers happy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Bold Subscriptions alternative has the lowest total cost for a small store?
Seal Subscriptions and Appstle both offer free plans with 0% transaction fees. For stores under 50 subscriptions, Seal is completely free. Appstle's free plan supports up to $500/month in subscription revenue.
Do any Bold Subscriptions alternatives offer free migration from Bold?
Yes, several do. Recurpay offers free white-glove migration and has migrated 175+ brands from Bold in the last 90 days. Appstle and Loop also provide hands-on migration support at no extra cost.
Which Bold Subscriptions alternative is best for reducing subscriber churn?
Loop Subscriptions specializes in retention with personalized cancellation flows, smart dunning, and subscriber rewards. Their customers typically see 15-25% churn reduction compared to basic subscription apps.
Are there any Bold Subscriptions alternatives with no transaction fees at all?
Appstle, Seal Subscriptions, and Utterbond all offer 0% transaction fee plans. Appstle has 0% fees across all plans, while Seal and Utterbond offer 0% fees on their paid tiers.
How long does migration from Bold Subscriptions typically take?
Most migrations complete in 24-48 hours for the technical transfer, though you should plan 1-2 weeks total for testing and communication. Complex setups with custom integrations may take longer.
Can I try these Bold Subscriptions alternatives before committing?
Most offer free trials or free plans. Recurpay, Appstle, Seal, and Utterbond have free plans you can use indefinitely with limitations. Loop and Recharge offer trial periods, while Skio typically requires a demo call.
