80% of shoppers hang up if they hit your voicemail.
You have a team to handle the phones during the day, but your brand stays open long after they go home.
Keeping a high-end experience 24/7 usually means paying for a massive night shift or watching your hard-earned sales slip away to competitors.
And it gets worse.
In this article we will go overt the best eCommerce call center for after hour support.
First, we compare live agents to AI automation.
Then, we help you pick the best setup for your Shopify store.
Editor’s note: Want to hear some sample support calls made for your Shopify store?
- Just paste your store URL
- Get sample calls in under 20 seconds (no email required)
- Listen to demo calls for my store
What is an ecommerce after hours call center?
An ecommerce after hours call center is a service that takes care of customer phone calls outside of your normal business hours.
This means nights, weekends, and holidays are covered, so you can offer support around the clock.
The main goal is to give shoppers immediate help by answering questions, tracking orders, and capturing leads when your team isn't available.
Since 68% of consumers say they'd pay more for products from a company with great customer service, this kind of coverage can be important.
We'll compare the two main ways to do this: the traditional model with live human agents and the modern alternative using AI for phone support.
This visual breaks down the key differences between the two approaches.
The traditional approach: Live agents
Traditional after-hours services use teams of remote receptionists who act as an extension of your business.
These agents answer calls with a greeting you've approved and follow a script to handle simple tasks.
Companies like AnswerConnect, PATLive, and Continental Message Solution (CMS) specialize in providing this human touch.
Some customers appreciate this for the empathy and ability to navigate complex emotional situations.
How live agent services operate
The setup is straightforward. You forward your business phone line to the service when your office closes.
A live agent picks up, usually within a few rings, and follows your script to take a message, answer basic questions, or qualify a sales lead.
Many of these services can connect with common business tools.
For instance, AnswerConnect integrates with CRMs to log call details. However, these integrations often pass information along rather than performing actions in real-time within e-commerce platforms like Shopify.
Limitations of traditional services
While hearing a human voice can be reassuring, this model has some limitations for a modern online store.
The cost can be unpredictable. Most services charge by the minute, which can make your monthly bill a surprise.
For example, AnswerConnect's Entry plan gives you 200 minutes for $350/month, but if you go over, it costs $2.50 for each extra minute.
This can get expensive for businesses with a high volume of calls.
Scaling up isn't always easy. Human-staffed centers can get overwhelmed by a sudden increase in calls, like during a Black Friday sale.
Bringing on more agents to handle the rush takes time and money, which can be a challenge for a fast-moving e-commerce business.
The scope of tasks is often limited. Live agents generally follow a script. They can take messages or answer pre-written questions, but they typically can't perform more complex actions like initiating a product exchange or checking an order's real-time tracking status directly in a Shopify store.
They usually create a ticket for your team to handle later.
Consistency can be a factor. The human touch is valuable, but the quality of service can vary from one agent to the next.
The customer's experience often depends on the individual agent who answers the call.
Comparing popular live agent services
Here’s a quick look at the pricing and features for a few popular providers, based on what they share publicly.
The modern approach: AI-powered phone support
The approach to after-hours call centers has evolved significantly. Today's solutions use advanced conversational AI that can understand what callers are saying and solve customer issues independently.
An AI phone agent like Seth, the AI support rep from Ringly.io, uses real-time speech-to-text, deep integrations with platforms, and natural-sounding text-to-speech to have human-like conversations.
How AI-powered services work
When a customer calls, the AI agent answers immediately. It determines the caller's needs, whether they're asking, "Where is my order?" or "How do I start a return?" The AI then pulls real-time data from a Shopify store to give an accurate answer or complete the task on the spot.
A key difference is that an AI agent can resolve issues from start to finish, while traditional services often take a message.
As of late 2025, Seth resolves an average of 73% of calls for over 2,100 Shopify stores without human help.
For more complex or emotional issues, the AI is designed to recognize its limits.
It can transfer the call to a human agent with all the conversation details, so your team has the context needed to assist.
Advantages of AI-powered services
Using an AI-powered system for after-hours support offers several benefits, especially for growing e-commerce businesses.
AI is cost-effective and scalable. It typically comes with predictable pricing. Instead of per-minute charges that can be difficult to predict, many services offer a flat monthly fee.
An AI agent can handle one call or thousands simultaneously without a dip in performance, which is ideal for holidays and sales events.
It can integrate deeply with e-commerce platforms. A primary differentiator is this integration.
For example, an AI like Ringly.io's, built for Shopify, can look up order details or process returns directly within the system.
You get 24/7 consistency. The AI provides the same on-brand support on every call, any time of day.
It can also work in over 40 languages, allowing you to support a global customer base.
Setup can be fast. While a traditional answering service can take days to get running, an AI agent from Ringly.io can be set up in about three minutes by connecting your Shopify store.
Ringly.io pricing
Ringly.io's pricing is straightforward and designed to grow with your store.
- Start Plan: $99/month for 250 call minutes.
- Grow Plan: $349/month for 1,000 call minutes, which also includes a self-learning AI, call recordings, and analytics.
- Scale Plan: $1,099+/month for 3,000+ minutes, including custom setups and integrations.
Ringly.io also offers a guarantee: you pay nothing until Seth resolves at least 60% of calls during your trial period.
This ensures it's working for your business before you are billed.
How to choose an after-hours call center
Picking between a traditional service and AI comes down to your store's specific needs, call volume, and goals. Here are a few things to consider.
Evaluate cost and call volume
If you get very few after-hours calls, a pay-as-you-go plan like PATLive's Basic plan might seem suitable at first.
As your store grows, per-minute and overage fees can add up. A flat-rate subscription like Ringly.io's gives you predictable costs that are more manageable as you scale.
Assess task resolution needs
Ask a simple question: do you need someone to take a message, or do you need the customer's issue resolved on the first call?
For common e-commerce questions like "Where is my order?" or "I want to start a return," an AI agent with deep Shopify integration can be more efficient than a human agent who creates a support ticket for your team to handle the next day.
Consider the customer experience
Traditional services often emphasize the "human touch," with providers like AnswerConnect's pledge highlighting this aspect.
This can be beneficial for handling emotionally charged calls.
Modern AI offers a different type of positive experience: instant answers, no hold times, 24/7 consistency, and support in the customer's own language.
A well-designed AI helps customers avoid the frustration of long waits or getting different answers from different agents.
Think about speed and scalability
Consider how quickly you need to get started. An AI agent can be live in minutes, while traditional services often need a longer setup and training period. An AI solution also scales instantly for sales events, whereas human-powered services may require advance planning for staffing during busy times.
The future of after-hours support is intelligent
An ecommerce after hours call center is no longer a luxury; it's a key component for staying competitive. Shoppers expect 24/7 help, and if it's not provided, you could lose sales and customers.
We've looked at two options: the traditional live agent model, which offers a human touch but can be limited in scope and have unpredictable costs, and the modern AI-powered model, which is scalable, cost-effective, and deeply connected to e-commerce platforms.
For many growing Shopify stores, an AI phone agent like Seth from Ringly.io can be a strong option.
It combines the consistency of automation with the capability to solve most customer issues on the first call, creating a better experience for customers and a smoother workflow for your team.
Start automating your phone support today
Ready to explore a modern approach to customer support? With Ringly.io, you can offer 24/7 service and ensure you never miss a sales opportunity again.
The setup only takes a few minutes, and with a guarantee that you don't pay until it works, you can see how an AI agent can change your after-hours support.
Provide 24/7 support and capture every sale. Start your free Ringly.io trial and set up your AI phone agent in minutes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is an after hours call center important for my online store?
An after hours call center is important because customers shop at all hours and expect immediate support. If they can't get help with an order or a question, they might abandon their cart or shop with a competitor, leading to lost sales.
What's the main difference between a live agent and an AI-powered call center?
The main difference is in resolution. A live agent typically follows a script to take messages and create support tickets for your team to handle later. An AI-powered service, especially one integrated with your store, can often resolve the customer's issue, like tracking an order or starting a return, on the very first call.
How much does an after hours call center typically cost?
Costs vary. Traditional live agent services often charge by the minute, which can become expensive with high call volumes. Modern AI solutions like Ringly.io usually offer a flat monthly fee based on call minutes, which provides more predictable pricing as your business grows.
Can an after hours call center integrate with my Shopify store?
Yes, especially modern AI solutions. A service like Ringly.io is built specifically for Shopify, allowing its AI agent to access real-time order information, process returns, and answer specific questions directly from your store's data. Traditional services may have CRM integrations, but they typically can't perform actions within Shopify.
How quickly can I set up an after hours call center?
Setup time depends on the type of service. Traditional live agent services can take several days for setup and training. An AI-powered solution like Ringly.io can be up and running in just a few minutes after connecting it to your Shopify store.
What happens if a call center can't solve a customer's problem?
Both types of services have procedures for escalation. A live agent will take detailed notes and create a ticket for your team. A well-designed AI agent is trained to recognize when an issue is too complex or emotional and will transfer the call to a human on your team, providing them with the full context of the conversation.
